Monochrome and Creative Competitions 13 December 2016  

Two very contrasting competitions were judged during the evening by Andy Beel FRPS who was welcomed back to the club by Chairman Richard Watson LRPS.
The prints were shown first and Andy who is a renowned monochrome print worker himself commented on the 32 entries and remarked that many images were to him almost an all over grey and that an effort should be made to add 'punch' to the prints by enhancing the contrast in the editing.
Case TPThe important factor is the direction of the light - side or back lighting gives much more interesting effects than straight on lighting and Andy commented that the lightest part of the image is where the viewers' attention is drawn and should be the main subject of the image. Some images had overblown skies and Andy recommended setting the exposure on the camera for the sky or lightest part of the image so as not to lose detail as then the darker areas can be lightened in post processing.

gambian girlAn entry by Tim Pier titled 'On the Case' (right) was awarded first place, Andy said it was an interesting subject with very good lighting and composition and was well printed. 'Pathway to the square was another print by Tim that was judged to have  a good leading line that drew the eye to the light through the archway and it was placed third.
It was the eyes and soulful expression of a young Gambian girl (left) portrayed by Dave Gray that the judge admired and that gained second place. Only four Highly Commended's were awarded although the rules allowed more but Andy felt that other prints although he had praised them did not deserve an award.
Richard Atkinson AFIAP and Stuart Barnes were each awarded an HC and Kyra Wilson did well with 2 HC's.

Adragonfter the break the Creative entries were projected and Andy said he was right out of his comfort zone with this type of competition and it was not the type of image he was used to judging.
There was a great variety of interesting techniques among the 44 entries - some in camera and some in the post processing. Andy confessed that some images he did not understand and others were not to his taste.
Members seemed to really enjoy seeing the interesting and sometimes extraordinary efforts from fellow members who had experimented with various filters that resulted in some very different images to those that they are usually associated with.

Andy gave his comments on the images and held back 6 images on which he then commented and expressed his reasons why he gave them the awards.
ChoirA montage by Pam Mullings was awarded first place - titled 'Choir Practice' (left) portraying owls instead of choir boys, Andy said he liked the composition and the expressions of some of the owls depicted.
Another image by Pam was placed third this time featuring a man 'Haunted' by an eerie ghost from the past.
Smoke images from Kev Ferris LRPS - one titled 'Dragon Lord' (right) was in second place and 'The Ballerina' gained an HC.
Janet Rutter LRPS and Robert Harvey ARPS EFIAP were the only other entrants to gain awards in the Creative competition.
Thanks to all those who entered and had fun creating their images.

Members present had the pleasure of seeing both traditional monochrome prints and more experimental digital images during the same evening so hopefully something for everyone.
Thanks to Andy for judging and giving his comments on both sets of entries and for those members who entered such a variety of images. PM
Full results                    All the awarded images can be seen in the Galleries